Yet, nazis in general and himmler in particular liked it a lot, and this is what earned it a place in an imaginary tophundred list of most dangerous books ever written, established by the italian. The point was that germany for many centuries was but a. In the end the roman historian tacitus did not write a most dangerous book. The following, which completes the text of the germania, is from an 18thcentury different translation bythomas gordon. The second part, in which tacitus gives a geographical account of the locations of the main german tribes is from the 18thcentury translation by thomas gordon. Once i finished reading the actual germania, so that i could understand this one, i was able to get started. Apr 29, 2012 free kindle book and epub digitized and proofread by project gutenberg. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading a most dangerous book. I recently finished christopher krebs a most dangerous book the blurb of which states that it is about the roman writer tacitus on how his book the germania has been abuse throughout the ages. Hitler pronounced a eulogy, talking about germanic state of the germanic nation. The various peoples of germany are separated from the gauls by the rhine, from the raetians and pannonians by the danube, and from the sarmatians and dacians by mountains or, where there are no mountains, by mutual fear. Krebs on the role roman historian cornelius tacitus played in defining the german people through a small volume called germania written in a. The story of how a pamphlet of observations of ancient germany, written by the roman tacitus, over almost 2 millennia ago was reinterpreted through the ages helped shape nazi racial policy.
Apr 09, 2014 as christopher krebs shows in a most dangerous book. The germania is a most dangerous book not because it fitted the frame but because it had helped to form it 22. The germania cisrhenana, divided into the upper and lower, was a part of gallia belgica. Tacituss germania from the roman empire to the third reich, is that it was a roman who did most to define and. In recent decades, however, there have been important scholarly developments that significantly affect.
Jun 30, 2011 in 1954, less than a decade after the fall of the third reich, the great italianjewish historian arnaldo momigliano told an important international classical congress that cornelius tacitus brief ethnographical pamphlet on the ancient germans was among the one hundred most dangerous books ever written. Sources edit tacitus makes use of the official sources of the roman state. Full text of tacitus, the agricola and germania see other formats. He was a contemporary and friend of the younger pliny, who addressed to him some of his most famous epistles. Tacitus germania from the roman empire to the third reich by christopher krebs. Krebs is a young academic, but he has produced a model of popular intellectual. In doing so, be warned, he was commenting on the rome of his own time, as much as on the german themselves chapter 1 geography of germany. The title is very preposterous in spite of the letter a. Krebs follows a convoluted thread from the roman author tacitus in 98 ad to the rise of nazism in germany nearly 2000 years later. A most dangerous book is an interesting academic study on the development of racial thought in germany. But the germania inspired and polarized readers long before the rise of the third reich. Himmler but also saying that national socialism was not. If i looked like himmler, i wouldnt even mention the word race. Krebs draws attention to another part of the explanation for germanys existence the role played by tacitus himself, through the influence of a small volume called germania.
Text to this point from tacitus, the agricola and germania, a. Tacituss germania from the roman empire to the third reich new york. Tacituss germania from the roman empire to the third reich krebs. According to christopher krebs, assistant professor of the classics in the faculty of arts and sciences, tacitus germania deserves a spot on the roster. A most dangerous book is a most brilliant achievement. A most dangerous book deals with a short and sober ethnographic description written almost two thousand years ago by the roman historian cornelius tacitus. When tacitus wrote a notveryflattering little book about the ancient germans in 98 ce, at the height of the roman empire, he could not have foreseen that the. In every way, a most dangerous book is a most brilliant achievement. Tacituss germania from the roman empire to the third reich, german nationalists and their coterie of militarist partisans used germania to testify to the moral superiority of the ancient germanic peoples. Tacitus germania a most dangerous book by christopher b. This book s title suggests the world might have been better off if germania had never turned up, but the text reveals that krebs himself doesnt feel tacitus s book is dangerous or the urtext of nazi ideology or even an ethnography, but a stereotypical roman view of the outsider.
Ancient text has long and dangerous reach harvard gazette. Krebs traces the book, actually a tract of less than 30 pages, from the hand of roman historian tacitus to the hands of nazi leaders in the third reich. A most dangerous book tacitus germania from the roman. Germania tacitus, an important roman historian, wrote the most detailed early description of the germans at then end of the first century ce. In this elegant and captivating history, christopher b. Share on twitter share on facebook share on linkedin. That is the question i kept in mind as i read christopher krebs a most dangerous book. The world s most dangerous book download ebook pdf, epub. Tacitus germania from the roman empire to the third reich.
The dates of the birth and death of tacitus are uncertain, but it is probable that he was born about 54 a. In short, krebs emphasizes, tacitus did not write a most dangerous book. Tacituss germania from the roman empire to the third reich as want to read. Pdf agricola and germania download full pdf book download. The agricola is both a portrait of julius agricola the most famous governor of roman britain and tacitus wellloved and respected fatherinlaw and the first detailed account of britain that has come down to us. Krebs, a professor of classics at harvard university, traces the wideranging influence of the germania, revealing how an ancient text rose to take its place among the most dangerous books in the world. May 02, 2011 the riveting story of the germania and its incarnations and exploitations through the ages. Because of its influence on the ideologies of pangermanism and nordicism, jewishitalian historian arnaldo momigliano in 1956 described germania and the iliad as among the most dangerous books ever written. These writers, politicians, and agitators saw in tacitus account a clear history. A most dangerous book tacitus germania from the roman empire to the third reich christopher b. Tacituss germania from the roman empire to the third reich, a newly published study by harvard classicist christopher b. The riveting story of the germania and its incarnations and exploitations through the ages. The germania, as it became to be known in modern times, did not seem dangerous to anybody for centuries, and neither does it today.
Krebs, in a most dangerous book, neatly characterizes it as sparkling and serrated. Germania is an early work by tacitus circa 56120, whose greatest. Think of it as an ancient exercise in social anthropology. Tacitus s germania from the roman empire to the third reich. The germania of tacitus is the most extensive account of the ancient germans written during the roman period, but has been relatively neglected in the scholarship of the englishspeaking world. In his fascinating new study, a most dangerous book, christopher b. Read download most dangerous book in the world pdf pdf download. Krebs draws attention to another part of the explanation for germanys existence the role played by tacitus himself. Roman historian cornelius tacitus short early work germania, written just after the reign of the tyrant domitian and probably as a political challenge in the. Tacitus germania download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl, mobi. Tacitus owes most, both in language and in method, to sallust, and ammianus marcellinus is the later historian whose work most closely approaches him in style. Tacituss germania from the roman empire to the third.
Both promise to deliver an account of the history of a famous book of antiquity. The various peoples of germany are separated from the. Apr 01, 2011 my interest in christopher krebs a most dangerous book was first aroused in part because of my interest in stephen greenblatts the swerve. When tacitus wrote a notveryflattering little book about the ancient germans. One of the most dangerous books ever written is surely the bible, with all parts of it. Tacitus germania from the roman empire to the third reich a most dangerous book. The pope wanted it, montesquieu used it, and the nazis pilfered an italian nobles villa to get it. I enjoyed it so much that i bought the leopold classic library edition of tacitus agricola, germania and dialogue on oratory. Ask a wellread individual to list the most dangerous books in history, and a few. The first half of this etext from tacitus, the agricola and germania, a.
1091 971 1061 731 1390 872 1115 1311 878 568 120 1596 1577 1246 1283 1626 607 1121 1456 1441 284 963 737 352 784 1374 1092 379 320 211 1185 1326 1474 193 1231